POLL: Should Children Be Able To Use Facebook?
The social-networking site is apparently mulling over the idea.
Facebook is developing technology that would allow those under the age of 13 to use the site under parental supervision, a move that could help bring in a sea of new users for revenue but that could also increase privacy concerns, according to a report in Monday's Wall Street Journal.
The technology being tested would allow children's accounts to be tied to their parents' accounts so that parents would decide whom their children could "friend." New kid-friendly features also could allow Facebook and its partners to bill parents for games and other entertainment accessed by their kids.
Currently Facebook bans those under the age of 13.
But several studies show that many kids use Facebook despite the ban, often with their parents' consent.
For example, a 2011 Consumer Reports survey discovered that 7.5 million people younger than 13 already use Facebook.
As a result, some argue that the ban should be removed so that adults could work more openly with their children on the issue of social networking.
Technology journalist Larry Magid wrote in The Huffington Post that: "Whether we like it or not, millions of children are using Facebook, and since there doesn't seem to be a universally effective way to get them off the service, the best and safest strategy would be to provide younger children with a safe, secure and private experience that allows them to interact with verified friends and family members without having to lie about their age."
But many have criticized the idea of lifting the ban.
Common Sense Media, an advocacy group, compared Facebook to "Big Tobacco."
"With the growing concerns and pressure around Facebook's business model, the company appears to be doing whatever it takes to identify new revenue streams and short-term corporate profits to impress spooked shareholders," the group's CEO, James Steyer, said in a statement.
"But here's the most important issue: There is absolutely no proof of any meaningful social or educational value of Facebook for children under 13. Indeed, there are very legitimate concerns about privacy as well as the impact on the social, emotional and cognitive development of children. What Facebook is proposing is similar to the strategies used by Big Tobacco in appealing to young people—try to hook kids early, build your brand, and you have a customer for life.
"What's next? Facebook for toddlers?"
No doubt parents and kids have had many heated discussions over Facebook in recent years as the site has grown in popularity.
Earlier this year, a YouTube video was made by an angry father who, when fixing his daughter’s computer, came across her long Facebook rant about family life. He was so mad about her post that he spilled his own rant, which he promised to post on his daughter's Facebook wall. For his grand finale, the dad pulled out a gun and shot his daughter's laptop to pieces.
The YouTube video became an instant sensation.
What do you think? Take our poll and tell us what you think about this idea in the comments section below.
Concerned Resident
9:16 am on Tuesday, June 5, 2012
Although many children already use Facebook, young children to not understand the consequences of their actions well enough. Although parents can install software and otherwise supervise computer usage, it is hard enough to stay on top of that already. And Facebook makes it very difficult for a parent to "friend" a child or close the account if that parent wants to do so.
People who say that the kids are already using it makes for a poor reason to allow it if it is a problem. Where does the line stop of this reasoning? My kid smokes pot anyway so I should permit that? I don't think so. It's not the same thing? No, but it has its own issues.
sp resident
11:20 am on Tuesday, June 5, 2012
Shame on Zuckerberg,why would you want kids to display all their private info on the internet, I guess he needs to make more money. Wake up parents, this is not what you want your kids on, keep their lives private as much as you can. Kids are already addicted to tv, video games and computers, now something else to get them addicted too. Read a book!
Robert Wendel
11:30 am on Tuesday, June 5, 2012
I think this is a horrible idea. I won't allow my kids to use Facebook nor do I use it. It is amazing that people don't understand the gravity of surrendering their privacy on Facebook.
bgporter
11:49 am on Tuesday, June 5, 2012
COPPA (http://www.coppa.org/)is well intentioned, but ultimately too broad, and as a result is generally ignored (by the same token, I can't create an email account for my daughter on gmail to use to communicate with her teachers or grandparents unless I lie about her age). This is a decision that should be made by parents for their own children.
Alison McGruber
10:10 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
This is indeed difficult for older parents with adolescents who sit at home all day on Facebook.
Julie
11:15 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
I agree with you, bgporter.
Alison McGruber
10:15 am on Thursday, June 7, 2012
There are many wonderful programs for senior citizens within our communities.
Let these old folks get out and about so as not to have this time on their hands and worrying about our young folks out there.